11/24/2020

Nikolai Myaskovsky - Piano Sonatas: Vol.3 - Nos.7, 8 & 9


 


Piano Sonatas Vol.3

Rondo-Sonata Op.58
Sonata No.8, Op.83
Sonata No.9, Op.84
Reminiscences Op.29
Sonata No.7, Op.82
Yellowed Leaves Op.31
Scherzo from String Quartet No.5 
(Transcribed by A.Aliawdina)

Murray McLachlan (Piano)

recorded 18-19 Dec 1990, Holmbury St Mary Church Hall, England

Here Olympia switch recording halls for volume 3. They abandon Norway and move to a British church hall. Marco Polo also decamped and moved their set up to a different location for their volume 3 although they stayed in Budapest with Hegedüs.

The bravura Rondo-Sonata, another legacy of the Tbilisi years (and, by the way, not at all exotic), is perfectly weighted, clear of texture, bright-eyed and heroic. Then come the two short and very accessible sonatas: numbers 8 and 9, each no more than 14 minutes long. The ten minute Seventh comes later. The Chorale-Rondo (No. 8) manages to pull off Mozartian and Russian folkishness. The six Reminiscences (1927): No. 1 simple grace with some harmonic spice; No. 2 like one of Rachmaninov's more virtuosic Preludes - tense and macabre; No. 3 pessimistic journeying; No. 4 Chopin-like with surprises in the tonality; a thoughtful lentamente with depressive tendencies; No. 6 - a Godowskian flight superbly powered and flighted by McLachlan. Yellowed Leaves Op. 31: No. 1 a hypnotic, tolling Andante; No. 2 tending to reflection; No. 3 andante cantabile; No. 4 fanciful Godowskian revels with a collapse into dark realms; No. 5 a haunting Molto calmo resolved in poised crystal clarity. No. 6 rapid insectile wingbeats pave the way for a noble tune touched with Celtic beauty. Aliawdina's transcription of the Scherzo from the String Quartet No. 5 - a popular work in the old USSR - reminds us of Rimsky's Bumble Bee flight before taking refuge in Miaskovsky's warmed and warming dewy nostalgia. Why do we not hear this piece at music competitions?

Rob Barnett

OVERVIEW

As things stand the recommendation has to go to the Olympia discs which are more generously timed and which have the perceptive virtuosic strengths of McLachlan. Hegedüs is no mean player and he is given a warmer and less objective image by the Marco Polo engineers by comparison with McLachlan's Olympia team. His recordings give great pleasure however McLachlan's power, verve and sensitivity are to be preferred. When the three Marco Polos drop to the Naxos price range things will be more evenly balanced.

8 comments:

Xanturios said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
rev.b said...

Thank you for all three.

classic said...

Thank you very much :)

danvarber said...

Link offline. I would be pleased if you reup this. Thanks and regards.

Xanturios said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
gmjgmjgmj said...

Any chance for a re-up? Thank you

Xanturios said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Xanturios said...

New link:

https://nitroflare.com/view/8DDB8FE9561A58D/MyaskovskyPianoSonatas7-8-9.rar