Hans Rott (1854-1884)
Symphony in E major
Cincinnati Philharmonia Orchestra
Gerhard Samuel (conductor)
A good performance of a fascinating work
The single symphony by Hans Rott (1858-1884), composed in 1878, has fared very well on disc, but this Hyperion release has the honor of being the first. Before its first release Rott was, as far as I can tell, more or less completely unknown, and the recording at hand was received as something of a revelation: a symphony that in more or less a single, fell swoop made us understand precisely where Mahler came from. The reaction is actually somewhat understandable (not the least because Mahler himself noted that “[Rott’s] innermost nature is so akin to mine that he and I are like two fruits from the same tree”). There are some remarkable foreshadowings of Mahler in Rott’s symphony – some commentators have even suggested that Mahler’s second symphony is occasionally more than just inspired by Rott’s work. Of course, Rott’s work isn’t quite on the level of Mahler’s in terms of inspiration. Despite its originality and good ideas Rott’s symphony isn’t a full-blown masterpiece; there are clumsy passages (sometimes the scoring is rather dense, for instance) and parts that come close to note-spinning.
Then again, the work is remarkable not only for foreshadowing Mahler, but from its indebtedness to Bruckner’s symphonies (it’s telling that Bruckner was the only one among the composers to whom Rott showed the work who actually seemed impressed) – calling it a “missing link” between Bruckner and Mahler seems eminently justifiable. The opening of the work, for instance, sounds quite a bit like a Bruckner symphony, though as it develops hints of Wagner and Schumann become audible as well. The third movement is the one that is closest to Mahler, especially Mahler’s first symphony – close enough for the connection to be striking. The fourth movement, however, is indebted to Brahms, in particular Brahms’s first symphony, though Rott is not afraid to avoid a kind of Wagnerian bombast that would be very foreign to Brahms. So, yes – Rott’s symphony really does try to do is to combine the influences of very different composers, but to his credit he succeeds better than one could reasonably expect and in the process he manages to create a sound world that really is remarkably original.
As mentioned the work has done well on disc, and all credit to Hyperion, Gerhard Samuel and the Cincinnati Philharmonia Orchestra for reviving it. They also do a fine job of it; the performances are committed and clean. The Cincinnati Philharmonia is, however, a student orchestra, and there are passages that hang fire, and the textures aren’t quite as opulent as they ideally should be. The disc at hand also suffers in competition with other recordings by the fact that it doesn’t offer any coupling (other recordings have unearthed various other Rott scores). So while this release deserves much praise for uncovering this work, this disc has, to some extent, been superseded. It’s still a good performance, however, and the sound quality is good.


6 comments:
Thank you!
nitroflare links are dead.
New link:
https://nitroflare.com/view/D2A1114F8A39891/RottSymphony1Hyp.rar
Fantastic. Thank you, Xanturios.
Post a Comment