1/24/2026

Arthur Benjamin - Symphony No.1; Ballade for String Orchestra



Arthur BENJAMIN (1893-1960)

Symphony No. 1 (1944-45)
Ballade For String Orchestra (1947)

Queensland Symphony Orchestra
Christopher Lyndon-Gee

Recorded February, 1995 at the ABC Music Centre, Ferry Road, Brisbane, Australia.
Co-produced by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.


Review:

Arthur Benjamin is known to most of us for his Jamaican Rumba. Not surprisingly his First Symphony is not a bit like this jolly, tuneful piece. It was written in 1944-5 and surely reflects the composer’s feelings about the international conflict, for he had served in both world wars. The symphony opens disconsolately, and violent drumbeats are soon declaring a harshness of mood that is to permeate most of the work. The writing in the first movement is essentially anguished, although a more confident, chorale-like tune on the strings offers contrast. The movement has plenty of energy and its basic tempo soon develops into a kind of restless march. The music is not short of ideas but symphonically doesn’t seem very coherent: Benjamin’s style of writing is rhapsodic and here sounds rather like film music without a film.
I liked the scherzo best. It is ear-ticklingly insubstantial at the opening but very soon the vehement brass harshens the texture before the shimmering orchestral delicacy returns to end the movement with lacy fragility. The Adagio appassionato begins on the violins in a mood of driving despair. There is a more restrained but still melancholy oboe tune, and a nervous repeated rhythmic figure leads to the continuation of the tragic string cantilena, which, with support from the brass, develops an agonized intensity before slowly becoming more subdued. The finale again takes up a martial tread and, at its climax, the opening of the first movement is recalled to provide a certain organic cohesion; the coda, however, despite being given weight and brightness by the trumpets, remains ambivalent.
The Ballade is hardly less sombre in tone, and has much in common with the symphony, again expressing its neurosis through a powerful ongoing violin cantilena. This music cannot be easy to play and the strings of the Queensland orchestra are impressive; especially in the bursts of violent bravura, Christopher Lyndon-Gee responds to the forceful emotional thrust this music carries. The recording is good, spacious but just slightly two-dimensional in the fiercest tuttis.

 Ivan March (Gramophone)

3 comments:

Xanturios said...

Flac tracks, covers and booklet

https://nitroflare.com/view/E0AE31A70FC36FD/BenjaminASymph1Ballade.rar

Tanchelijn said...

I didn't know these interesting works. Thank you, Xanturios.

classic said...

Thank you very much :)