12/14/2025

Beethoven for Three - Symphonies Nos. 2 & 5



Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)

Symphony No. 2 in D major, Op. 36 (arr. Ferdinand Ries)
Symphony No. 5 in C minor, Op. 67 (arr. Colin Matthews) 

Leonidas Kavakos (violin), Yo-Yo Ma (cello), Emanuel Ax (piano) 


Symphony No. 2 arrangement for piano trio attributed to Ferdinand Ries, under the supervision of the composer.
Symphony No. 5 arrangement for piano trio by Colin Matthews.


Recorded August 1-4, 2021

Review:

This is the second recording from a superstar trio whose individual players have already notched up a fair few Beethoven discs. But here are pieces usually out of soloists’ reach, performed in arrangments for piano trio.

Symphony No. 2 is played in an arrangement by one of Beethoven’s own pupils, Ferdinand Ries. If Liszt turned the piano into an orchestra with his arrangement of this piece, Ries opts for the opposite tack. His scaled-back symphony is pure chamber music, and the trio play it as such. The ensemble sounds as one: supple, elegant – and, dare I say it, ever so slightly bland.

For playing that honours Beethoven’s radical quality, listen to this performance of Colin Matthews’ fresh and unexpected arrangement of the Fifth. A gifted orchestrator, here Matthews performs the magic trick in reverse. His gift is that while he gets right into the voice of a composer, neither diminishing nor diluting it, his versions are yet somehow tinged with his own individual twist – you can hear it in the way he uses one of the instruments to double another, just for an instant, or how a melody seamlessly glides between violin and cello. This is a Beethoven Five to return to and savour.

Rebecca Franks

5 comments:

Xanturios said...

Flac tracks, covers and booklet

https://nitroflare.com/view/D90ACE7B6AEA682/Beethovenfor3-Symphs2and5.rar

Pippo said...

Thanks, Xanturios. These arrangements (when well-crafted, of course) always clarify the composer's writing and offer a more detailed view of the musical ideas. This concept reminds me of the four-hand piano versions of symphonic pieces. And then I must also say that the performers are of stellar quality. Definitely an enjoyable, interesting, and informative post.
Thank you again

Xanturios said...

Thanks for your comment!!!

Appassionato said...

Many thanks!

classic said...

Three of the best musicians of our days! I've heard their recording of the 6th Symphony (Pastorale) and enjoyed it.
I especially love the piano trio music, by the way.
Thank you very much :)