8/11/2018

Alexander Scriabin - Symphony No.1, Op.26



Alexander SCRIABIN (1872-1915)

Symphony No. 1, in F Major, Op.26

Yevgenia Gorokhovskaya (mezzosoprano)
Konstantin Pluzhnikov (tenor)

Leningrad Glinka Academy Choir
USSR Radio Symphony Orchestra

Vladimir Fedoseyev 


The differences between Fedoseyev's and Muti's performances of this Symphony may represent differences between Soviet and Western attitudes to Scriabin and traditions of performing his music; they are certainly striking. Fedoseyev is much more inclined to keep the music moving, keener on ardour and aspiration than voluptuous lingering. It is characteristic of his approach that he should take the outer (slow) movements quite conspicuously faster than Muti, making the first seem like a delicate and freshly lyrical prelude (though one would hardly call it a lento, which is Scriabin's marking), the last a stylistically awkward but resolute choral epilogue to a Symphony which to all intents and purposes, ended with the preceding (fifth) movement. I found both of them convincing in Fedoseyev's handling, and was glad of the extra touch of urgent drama that he brings to the two big allegro movements; Muti's subtle responsiveness to the ebb and flow of rubato and his beautiful moulding of texture and detail do hold up the impetus of this music a trifle. But in the Tristanesque yearning of the third movement and the mercurial delicacy of the fourth Fedoseyev's choices of tempo strike me as less well-judged: the scherzo sounds cautious, even a shade gawky (Muti's feathery lightness of touch is ideal here), while the central lento isn't given room, at Fedoseyev's poco adagio, to generate the gripping sense of febrile but sustainedly eloquent argument that Muti gives it.
But then in the West we are inclined to think of Scriabin as a poet of exquisite fin-de-siecle decadence; in Russia, I suspect—and not only in Russia, these days—he would be classed as a proto-modernist, and Fedoseyev's reading is in perfect accord with that view. I love the shimmering sensuousness of Muti's version (and EMI's opulent rendering of it), I respect and admire Fedoseyev's demonstration that another view of the music is perfectly valid. The recording (which originates from Melodiya) is well-suited to the leaner, more emphatic work that the Symphony becomes in his hands, and the orchestral playing is excellent.'

Gramophone.com

3 comments:

Xanturios said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
classic said...

Thank you very much :)

Xanturios said...

New link:

https://nitroflare.com/view/E01FB88D8D25D29/ScriabinSymphonyNo1.rar