Pierre Rode (1774-1830)
24 Caprices for Solo Violin
24 Caprices for Solo Violin
Axel Strauss, Violin
In the days before Suzuki’s method swept almost everything before it,
making way for a brave new world in which violinists moved through
limited numbers of pieces to full concertos, virtually bypassing
technical études, students customarily took a different road to the
summit. That one, well worn through the ages, passed through the
foothills of Rodolphe Kreutzer’s 40 (or 42), ascending arduously by
way of Federigo Fiorillo’s 36 to Pierre Rode’s 24 before mounting to
the pinnacle of Paganini’s almost unattainable 24.
In those days, students even stopped to study a concerto or two by
Viotti, Kreutzer, Rode, or Spohr before tackling standard repertoire.
To those students, Rode’s caprices represented welcome relief from
studies focused each on a single technical problem; compare Rode’s
miniatures, which tied together various problems in knots although
still perhaps emphasizing one or another of them. It should come as
no surprise, then, that Rode’s caprices have been among the first
sets (besides Paganini’s, and perhaps Ernst’s technical barn burners
and Wieniawski’s barnstorming op. 10—the École moderne —and op. 18)
to be recorded (in Rode’s case, by Cristina Giovannini on Stradivarius
51 and by the “last of the Auer students,” Oscar Shumsky).
making way for a brave new world in which violinists moved through
limited numbers of pieces to full concertos, virtually bypassing
technical études, students customarily took a different road to the
summit. That one, well worn through the ages, passed through the
foothills of Rodolphe Kreutzer’s 40 (or 42), ascending arduously by
way of Federigo Fiorillo’s 36 to Pierre Rode’s 24 before mounting to
the pinnacle of Paganini’s almost unattainable 24.
In those days, students even stopped to study a concerto or two by
Viotti, Kreutzer, Rode, or Spohr before tackling standard repertoire.
To those students, Rode’s caprices represented welcome relief from
studies focused each on a single technical problem; compare Rode’s
miniatures, which tied together various problems in knots although
still perhaps emphasizing one or another of them. It should come as
no surprise, then, that Rode’s caprices have been among the first
sets (besides Paganini’s, and perhaps Ernst’s technical barn burners
and Wieniawski’s barnstorming op. 10—the École moderne —and op. 18)
to be recorded (in Rode’s case, by Cristina Giovannini on Stradivarius
51 and by the “last of the Auer students,” Oscar Shumsky).
Now Axel Strauss has entered the lists with a recording that will make
the works readily and inexpensively available to violinists—teachers
and students and professionals most obviously, perhaps—but also,
because of their musical merit, to general listeners as well. And from
his commanding opening of the First Caprice, it’s clear that the value
of his approach should be enormous; for from the work, devoted, like
Kreutzer’s Sixth Étude, largely to staccato, he draws a musical line
if not so cogent as those that Bach imbedded in his leaping melodies,
at least recognizable and captivating to a musical sensibility.
His tone on the 1845 Pressenda on which he plays displays a variety of
timbres that also brings the study closer to a character piece than to
a technical exercise. The Second Caprice, with its octaves and string
crossings, sounds more dazzling, while Strauss spins long-breathed
patterns from the Third’s perpetual-motion-like legato 16th notes.
And he dispels any doubt about the Romantic sensibilities of these
caprices in the Fourth’s Allegro, which, though regular in its
patterns, strikes the listener with the force of a gale wind.
In Strauss’s reading, the Fifth, though brilliant, continues the dark
mood of the Fourth (every traditional student, though perhaps not yet
capable of Strauss’s tempestuous assaults, should have felt the
exhilaration of playing real, portentous music—perhaps for the first
time—when tackling this study). The Sixth opens with cantilena on
the G string, of which Strauss takes optimum advantage,
playing the 16th notes that bring the introduction to a close with
yearning sensitivity. Comparing the scale-like patterns of the ensuing
Moderato section with those in Kreutzer’s 26th (say) reveals how far
Rode had surpassed Kreutzer in both brilliance and cogency.
Strauss never seems to rush the studies at the expense of the music;
in the Seventh Caprice, he doesn’t sacrifice any of the message to
achieve extra crispness in the staccatos. He elicits rather than
electrifies, and he brings to the intensely patterned Eighth the same
kind of intelligent communication for which interpreters strive in Bach’s
movements that feature similarly steady patterns (though the Master’s
usually shift kaleidoscopically). In the jaunty Allegretto of the Ninth
Caprice, Strauss recalls the triplet figures in concertos written by his
teacher, Giovanni Battista Viotti. The 10th Caprice parks the student in
third position throughout, but Strauss reveals no left-hand fatigue.
He plays the 11th as a musical composition, supplying ample punctuation
rather than simply stringing the phrases in a single,
undifferentiated, sentence.
the works readily and inexpensively available to violinists—teachers
and students and professionals most obviously, perhaps—but also,
because of their musical merit, to general listeners as well. And from
his commanding opening of the First Caprice, it’s clear that the value
of his approach should be enormous; for from the work, devoted, like
Kreutzer’s Sixth Étude, largely to staccato, he draws a musical line
if not so cogent as those that Bach imbedded in his leaping melodies,
at least recognizable and captivating to a musical sensibility.
His tone on the 1845 Pressenda on which he plays displays a variety of
timbres that also brings the study closer to a character piece than to
a technical exercise. The Second Caprice, with its octaves and string
crossings, sounds more dazzling, while Strauss spins long-breathed
patterns from the Third’s perpetual-motion-like legato 16th notes.
And he dispels any doubt about the Romantic sensibilities of these
caprices in the Fourth’s Allegro, which, though regular in its
patterns, strikes the listener with the force of a gale wind.
In Strauss’s reading, the Fifth, though brilliant, continues the dark
mood of the Fourth (every traditional student, though perhaps not yet
capable of Strauss’s tempestuous assaults, should have felt the
exhilaration of playing real, portentous music—perhaps for the first
time—when tackling this study). The Sixth opens with cantilena on
the G string, of which Strauss takes optimum advantage,
playing the 16th notes that bring the introduction to a close with
yearning sensitivity. Comparing the scale-like patterns of the ensuing
Moderato section with those in Kreutzer’s 26th (say) reveals how far
Rode had surpassed Kreutzer in both brilliance and cogency.
Strauss never seems to rush the studies at the expense of the music;
in the Seventh Caprice, he doesn’t sacrifice any of the message to
achieve extra crispness in the staccatos. He elicits rather than
electrifies, and he brings to the intensely patterned Eighth the same
kind of intelligent communication for which interpreters strive in Bach’s
movements that feature similarly steady patterns (though the Master’s
usually shift kaleidoscopically). In the jaunty Allegretto of the Ninth
Caprice, Strauss recalls the triplet figures in concertos written by his
teacher, Giovanni Battista Viotti. The 10th Caprice parks the student in
third position throughout, but Strauss reveals no left-hand fatigue.
He plays the 11th as a musical composition, supplying ample punctuation
rather than simply stringing the phrases in a single,
undifferentiated, sentence.
The 13th Caprice shifts from sharps to flats, and though the absence of
open strings may darken the effect, Strauss supplies any want of
brilliance with a shifting, shadowy rhetoric. The 14th and 15th, in
Strauss’s performance, continue in this darker vein, with the 16th
revealing a particularly touching melody, tinged with chromatic harmonies,
flowing beneath its superficially étude-like patterns—and he declaims the
double-stopped passages with commanding authority. Similar chromatic
patterns underlie No. 17, Vivacissimo, despite the studies’ prima facie
dissimilarities. In No. 18, Strauss again reveals a Bach-like complexity
in the repeating patterns (recalling especially the Presto of the Master’s
First Solo Sonata). The broken octaves in the Allegretto of the 19th
Caprice deliver a musical message at the urgency of which similar patterns
in Kreutzer’s 25th Étude hardly hint. No. 20 brings another short character
piece, this one meditative despite its technical difficulties, and Strauss
reveals that the piece’s rhetorical gestures rather than challenges to
fingers and bow arm represent its most significant value for students.
Strauss struts cockily in the 21st Caprice and demonstrates an easy command
of the melodic leaps in the middle section as well as the decisive accents
throughout. The 22nd Caprice again elicits from Strauss a sense of
intelligent, Bach-like design. The 23rd Caprice recalls Pietro Locatelli’s
caprices from L’Arte del violino (those capriccios have never, to my
knowledge, been recorded independently of the concertos to which they
belong), and Strauss cements the connection. The 24th brings
the set to an impetuous conclusion.
open strings may darken the effect, Strauss supplies any want of
brilliance with a shifting, shadowy rhetoric. The 14th and 15th, in
Strauss’s performance, continue in this darker vein, with the 16th
revealing a particularly touching melody, tinged with chromatic harmonies,
flowing beneath its superficially étude-like patterns—and he declaims the
double-stopped passages with commanding authority. Similar chromatic
patterns underlie No. 17, Vivacissimo, despite the studies’ prima facie
dissimilarities. In No. 18, Strauss again reveals a Bach-like complexity
in the repeating patterns (recalling especially the Presto of the Master’s
First Solo Sonata). The broken octaves in the Allegretto of the 19th
Caprice deliver a musical message at the urgency of which similar patterns
in Kreutzer’s 25th Étude hardly hint. No. 20 brings another short character
piece, this one meditative despite its technical difficulties, and Strauss
reveals that the piece’s rhetorical gestures rather than challenges to
fingers and bow arm represent its most significant value for students.
Strauss struts cockily in the 21st Caprice and demonstrates an easy command
of the melodic leaps in the middle section as well as the decisive accents
throughout. The 22nd Caprice again elicits from Strauss a sense of
intelligent, Bach-like design. The 23rd Caprice recalls Pietro Locatelli’s
caprices from L’Arte del violino (those capriccios have never, to my
knowledge, been recorded independently of the concertos to which they
belong), and Strauss cements the connection. The 24th brings
the set to an impetuous conclusion.
Shumsky perhaps made a more brilliant effect in the brightest of the caprices,
but he seemed somewhat brittle in his pursuit of that effect, as well as
lacking Strauss’s tonal variety and compelling sense of style. As my son
remarked when I played various comparisons for him, Shumsky’s readings sound
more like studies, Strauss’s more like performances (performances to which,
I might add, general listeners might care to listen). That’s not to say that in
his roughly 10-minute shorter passage through the caprices, Shumsky doesn’t
display the full extent of his technical development; but these pieces teach
more than that, and Strauss has encompassed that additional territory.
Shumsky shows what a violinist can make of them; Strauss shows what a musician
can make of them. And Naxos’s engineers have captured their soloist in a rather
reverberant ambiance that sweetens the timbre of his violin.
but he seemed somewhat brittle in his pursuit of that effect, as well as
lacking Strauss’s tonal variety and compelling sense of style. As my son
remarked when I played various comparisons for him, Shumsky’s readings sound
more like studies, Strauss’s more like performances (performances to which,
I might add, general listeners might care to listen). That’s not to say that in
his roughly 10-minute shorter passage through the caprices, Shumsky doesn’t
display the full extent of his technical development; but these pieces teach
more than that, and Strauss has encompassed that additional territory.
Shumsky shows what a violinist can make of them; Strauss shows what a musician
can make of them. And Naxos’s engineers have captured their soloist in a rather
reverberant ambiance that sweetens the timbre of his violin.
Perhaps best of all (and unlike Elizabeth Wallfisch’s readings of
Kreutzer—cpo 999 901, Fanfare 32:4), Strauss’s performances of this didactic
literature don’t sound in the least mannered or intellectualized. Urgently
recommended to violinists, teachers, students, and professionals (to all of whom
his readings should provide at least an occasional epiphany)—and, in fact, to all
who don’t demand from Rode’s caprices the same musical nutrition they might
expect from Paganini’s caprices or Chopin’s études.
FANFARE: Robert Maxham
Kreutzer—cpo 999 901, Fanfare 32:4), Strauss’s performances of this didactic
literature don’t sound in the least mannered or intellectualized. Urgently
recommended to violinists, teachers, students, and professionals (to all of whom
his readings should provide at least an occasional epiphany)—and, in fact, to all
who don’t demand from Rode’s caprices the same musical nutrition they might
expect from Paganini’s caprices or Chopin’s études.
FANFARE: Robert Maxham


4 comments:
Originally uploaded by Daffy!
New Links:
http://nitroflare.com/view/74E9D0EF6FAD96C/Rode24Capric.rar
Many thanks and regards from The Netherlands.
Veel dank en groeten uit Nederland.
Would you mind re-posting please? Thank you.
Sorry but I lost all these Daffy's Rode's posts, gone with the crash of one of my HDs
Post a Comment