9/08/2012

Reinhold Gliere - Symphony No.1; The Red Poppy Suite




Reinhold GLIERE (1875-1956)

Symphony No. 1 in E flat, Op. 8 (1900) 
Suite from The Red Poppy, Op. 70 (1927)

BBC Philharmonic
Sir Edward Downes

Reinhold Glière is a really fascinating composer. His interest in folk music, considerable teaching abilities (Prokofiev, Khachaturian, Mosolov, Knipper and Miaskovsky were among his pupils), willingness to tow ‘the party line’ in terms of music ideology and avoidance of involvement in the post-revolution disputes between the Association of Contemporary Music (ACM) and the Russian Association of Proletarian Musicians (RAPM), kept him out of trouble with the Soviet authorities throughout his life, unlike so many others. Born on 11 January 1875 (30 December1874 by the old calendar) in Kiev to a father of German descent and a mother of Polish origin, Glière changed the spelling of his name from Glier in 1900, giving rise to the erroneous myth that he was of Belgian extraction. Though his father was an instrument-maker he did not want his son to study music, preferring him to become a doctor. Having insisted on his choice, he enrolled at the Moscow Conservatoire and was taught, among others, by Arensky, Ippolitov-Ivanov and Taneyev. Graduating in 1900 he accepted a teaching post at the Gnesin School of Music where the 11 year-old Prokofiev was in his class. Because of his interest in folk music he was often called upon to go to some of the far-flung regions of the USSR to assist local composers “create” a national musical style. Of course, it had to fit the socialist realist remit of “art that serves the people” mostly meaning that it should be readily understood by all sections of the people and be uncomplicated in its rhythmic style. Above all, it must be completely devoid of any “formalistic tendencies”, therefore not avant-garde. In this capacity he visited both Azerbaijan to develop the first prototype of an Azerbaijani national opera from which emerged his Shakh-Senem, since considered the cornerstone of the Soviet-Azerbaijani opera tradition (!), and Uzbekistan, where he worked alongside Uzbek composer Talib Sadykov, producing the overture Gyul’sara and the opera Leyli va Medzhnun. He was the recipient of three awards before the Revolution and many afterwards, including from Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan and several Stalin prizes. Here was a man who knew how to keep his musical nose clean. However, this does not mean that his music is unworthy of exposure. It should be remembered that it was the storm of protest from the cultural watchdogs, including Stalin himself following the premiere of Shostakovich’s ‘Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk’ that eventually led to the composition of his 5th symphony, subtitled “a Soviet artist’s reply to just criticism” which has since become his most popular work throughout the world.


________________________________

Glière’s First Symphony  is coupled with a much later work, his Suite from The Red Poppy, which had its premiere a full 27 years after the symphony. Another of David Nice’s articles in the accompanying booklet tells how in 1927, when that premiere took place along with Glière’s pupil Prokofiev’s The Love for Three Oranges, Prokofiev told his old friend and teacher how he and Dukelsky - another pupil who went on to make his name in the USA as Vernon Duke - would go for walks together and amuse themselves recalling their youth by humming the tunes from Glière’s first and second symphonies. Nice says that the two young men could hardly have chosen better models to study than “these two well-made symphonies”. I absolutely agree with that assessment as his first symphony has all the hallmarks of a master craftsman with no hint of a young man who is still exploring the symphonic genre. The symphony begins with the statement of a strong and lovely theme that is thoroughly exploited throughout the first movement, and it is the facility for full exploration of themes that I find so incredibly satisfying about Glière’s music; no musical stone is left unturned in milking every drop of melody from his themes. Each movement in fact is dominated by grand themes which make for a richness that is so exciting. Whilst the orchestral forces here are so much smaller than those used in his monumental third symphony the sound he gets from his orchestration is still writ large. This first main theme that begins in grandiose style is later given a much lighter, merrier treatment in almost dance style before being pulled back to being serious once more with the help of brass, then finishing on a more songlike, gentle note. The second movement begins with a balletic theme reminiscent of Tchaikovsky or even Delibes before a Russian folk song emerges to take control in 5/4 time but again with ballet-style treatment coming through every now and then in a struggle to assert itself. The third movement begins in a much more sober and reflective mood heavy with the melancholy nature of the “Russian soul”. It’s chock full of gorgeous melodies, whilst the finale doesn’t disappoint either. The latter’s introduction is full of Russian tunes which descend into a more sober mood before being dragged back into the light with echoes of the main theme from the first movement. The work finishes, to quote David Nice, with “a model ending to a blueprint symphony”.

As explained at the start of this review Glière always ensured he kept well within the aesthetic constraints of socialist realist diktats. The Suite from The Red Poppy is a perfect demonstration of this. It comes from the first truly Soviet ballet, despite, as David Nice writes, owing “far more to the lure of a glamorised China”; it is “Soviet” in the sense that it was written to appeal to all sections of society. The story tells of the love between a Soviet sailor and a Chinese girl who is killed by the sailor’s capitalist rival, aided by the dastardly British imperialist commandant of the port, as she tries to escape her homeland on board a Soviet ship. As she dies she gives her compatriots a red poppy and exhorts them to use it as their mascot in their fight for freedom - remember the red carnations that fighters stuck into the ends of their rifles during the Portuguese revolution of 1974. It is ironic that the Soviet authorities changed the ballet’s name in 1949 to The Red Flower so that no one would mistakenly associate the poppy with the Marxian phrase “Religion is the opium of the people” and see it as a metaphor for communism. The suite begins in rattling fashion with Heroic Coolie Dance in a quite convincing pastiche of Chinese music, followed by the setting out of the young couple’s love for each other, during which the opening bars of The Internationale are heard to emphasise the music’s revolutionary credentials. There follow two dances, both Chinese in flavour. Part IV is entitled “Phoenix” and is a lovely melody played on the solo violin of the BBC Philharmonic’s leader Dennis Simons, backed by the orchestra. It’s heavy with melancholy. The penultimate section is a waltz which is every bit as convincing as anything from the pen of the great Johann Strauss. The finale is a hugely satisfying and rumbustious Russian Sailor’s Dance which brings back more memories of the Cossack Dance in The Zaporozhy Cossacks. It must surely be a record to have ten distinct markings in a piece that lasts under four minutes! It is a Russian folk theme with variations played at different speeds from serious and sonorous to frantically lively. It conjures up a mental picture of dancers slapping their leather boots as they perform leaping and twirling ‘acroballetics’ - my invented word to describe acrobatics married to ballet. I would travel a long way to see the whole ballet as it should be as much a spectacle for the eyes as well as it is for the ears.




8 comments:

Horacio said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
itadiegues said...

Gracias Horatio.

Tubarec said...

¡Gracias por tanta música! ¿Puede resubir este disco, por favor?

Xanturios said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
adesito said...

Puedes subirla?

Xanturios said...

New link:

https://nitroflare.com/view/263A8A85C5D70ED/GliereSymph1RedPoppy.rar

adesito said...

Muchas gracias

classic said...

Thank you very much :)